Hofstede Revisited: Is Making the Ecological Fallacy when Using Hofstede’s Instrument on Individual Behavior Really Unavoidable?
- Tor Grenness
Abstract
This paper suggests that avoiding the ecological fallacy is - under certain circumstances - possible. One problem
in (cross-cultural) research is that there are often two levels of theorizing (individual and country) that needs to
be taken into account when data are being analyzed and conclusions are drawn. Typically, as is the case with
Hofstede's (1980) well-known research, cultural values are measured on country level. Consequently, researchers
who make causal inferences from such group data to individual behaviors are making the ecological fallacy, i.e
they (most often) wrongly assume that relationships observed for groups necessarily hold for individuals. If,
however, a method could be found that could help determining how individuals behave from the study of
aggregated data, the usefulness of Hofstede's research (and research on aggregated data in general) from a
manager's point of view would definitely increase.
In this paper the problem of the ecological fallacy, as well as different methods of avoiding it is discussed, and a
particular solution of the problem is suggested.
- Full Text: PDF
- DOI:10.5539/ijbm.v7n7p75
Journal Metrics
Google-based Impact Factor (2023): 0.86
h-index(2023): 152
i10-index(2023): 1168
Index
- Academic Journals Database
- ACNP
- AIDEA list (Italian Academy of Business Administration)
- ANVUR (Italian National Agency for the Evaluation of Universities and Research Institutes)
- Berkeley Library
- CNKI Scholar
- COPAC
- EBSCOhost
- Electronic Journals Library
- Elektronische Zeitschriftenbibliothek (EZB)
- EuroPub Database
- Excellence in Research for Australia (ERA)
- Genamics JournalSeek
- GETIT@YALE (Yale University Library)
- IBZ Online
- JournalTOCs
- Library and Archives Canada
- LOCKSS
- MIAR
- National Library of Australia
- Norwegian Centre for Research Data (NSD)
- PKP Open Archives Harvester
- Publons
- Qualis/CAPES
- RePEc
- ROAD
- Scilit
- SHERPA/RoMEO
- Standard Periodical Directory
- Universe Digital Library
- UoS Library
- WorldCat
- ZBW-German National Library of Economics
Contact
- Stephen LeeEditorial Assistant
- ijbm@ccsenet.org