On-Ice Assault: Difficulties in Discerning Consent in Canadian Ice Hockey


  •  Curtis Fogel    

Abstract

This paper considers the legal difficulties in prosecuting cases of on-ice violence in Canadian ice hockey, with particular attention to the consent defence. In this paper, a clear definition of consent is established to include: a voluntary agreement to participate in an activity that is free of coercion, deception, or fraud, and is arrived at in a clear mental state by all individuals involved. Using numerous legal case files and secondary literature, various issues of discerning consent in violent sport are discussed including: an unclear criminal code, the voluntary assumption of risk, the problem of line-drawing, honest but mistaken belief, the occurrence of non-specific contact, determining the intent of the accused, and determining liability. Various legal strategies to deal with the issues of discerning consent in violent sport are also discussed.



This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.